Skip to content

PYPLDigital payments

PayPal

Narrow moatHigh uncertainty

Updated

Price
$57.16
Fair value
fair value $80.00
Discount
28.6% below fair value
LSEG rating
LSEG 2.85 — lower is better (1–5)
Next earnings
Earnings Oct 27 · · estimated

Loading your notes…

In short

Thesis
Investors fear that PayPal keeps losing branded checkout share to other wallets and AI agents, so only years of steady checkout growth under the new CEO can close the gap.
Gap
Slow. The fear of share loss to other wallets and AI agents fades only after years of steady growth in branded checkout.
Next test
(estimate): Q3 2026 results: checkout and transaction margin

About

PayPal runs online payment services for consumers and merchants in about 200 markets. Its main products are PayPal branded checkout, the Venmo app for payments between people and to merchants, and Braintree, which processes card payments for large merchants without the PayPal brand. PayPal earns a fee on most payments, and branded checkout earns a higher margin than unbranded processing.

It also earns interest on customer balances and on its buy now, pay later and other loans, and it sells PayPal and Venmo debit and credit cards. In Q2 2026, it processed $486.4 billion of payments and had 439 million active accounts. Since April 2026, it runs three businesses: Checkout Solutions & PayPal, Consumer Financial Services & Venmo, and Payment Services & Crypto.

Thesis

The market fears that PayPal's most profitable business, branded checkout, will keep losing share. Apple Pay, Shop Pay and other wallets compete at the online checkout, and AI shopping agents, such as Meta's Muse, can move the purchase decision away from the PayPal button. In Q2 2026, payment volume grew 10%, but transaction margin dollars grew only 1% and the non-GAAP operating margin fell 248 basis points. Active accounts were almost flat at 439 million.

PayPal named Enrique Lores CEO in February 2026, and he started a new reorganization, so investors also wait to see whether the turnaround plan works. For the gap to close, three things must be true. Transaction margin dollars excluding interest on customer balances must grow faster than the 3% of Q2 2026, with branded checkout stable or growing. PayPal must reach its raised 2026 non-GAAP EPS guidance of about $5.38 while it keeps share buybacks near $1.5 billion a quarter.

Venmo must keep growing its revenue, and PayPal must win a share of payments that AI agents make, as with its Meta Muse checkout deal of September 2026. The Q3 report, expected in late October 2026, is the next test, and the Q4 report with the 2027 outlook in early February 2027 is the second. Because the fear of share loss to wallets and AI agents fades only with years of steady checkout growth, the gap can close only slowly.

Checkpoints

  1. Oct 27, 2026 · est.Pending
    Q3 2026 results: checkout and transaction marginTransaction margin dollars excluding interest on customer balances that grow faster than the 3% of Q2 and a 2026 EPS guidance kept near $5.38 pass; slower growth or a lower guidance fails.
  2. Feb 2027 · est.Pending
    Q4 2026 results and 2027 outlookA 2027 outlook with growth in non-GAAP EPS and transaction margin dollars passes; another year of falling margins fails.

Every passed and failed checkpoint across all picks

Balance sheet

Cash
$15.3B
Debt
$13.5B
Net cash
$1.8B
Interest cover
12×
times profit pays interest

Cash against debt

Cash$15.3B
Debt$13.5B

debt covered by cash

When the debt is due

12 months$2.5B
Later$11.0B

The last debt is due in 2062.

PayPal has more cash and investments than debt. At June 30, 2026, cash, cash equivalents and investments were $15.3 billion.

Risks

  • Apple Pay, Shop Pay and other wallets compete with PayPal branded checkout, which earns PayPal's highest margin. If PayPal keeps losing share at the online checkout, its profits can fall.
  • AI shopping agents from large technology companies can choose the payment method for the user. If these agents favor other wallets or take a fee, PayPal's role and margin at checkout can shrink.
  • A new CEO, a new structure and many leadership changes in 2026 bring execution risk. The turnaround can bring more charges and job cuts before growth returns.
  • PayPal holds buy now, pay later and other consumer loans. A weaker consumer can raise loan losses and reduce payment volume.

Recent events

  • October 5, 2026Venmo said that its credit card now pays up to 4% cash back on purchases that users split with friends.
  • September 22, 2026PayPal said that its customers will be able to shop and check out with Meta's Muse AI agent at PayPal merchants. PayPal did not give financial terms or a launch date.
  • July 28, 2026PayPal reported Q2 2026 results. Revenue rose 5% to $8.7 billion, and payment volume rose 10% to $486.4 billion. Transaction margin dollars rose 1% to $3.9 billion, and non-GAAP EPS fell 1% to $1.38. Free cash flow was $1.8 billion, and buybacks were $1.5 billion. PayPal raised its 2026 non-GAAP EPS guidance to about $5.38.
Show 2 older events
  • May 5, 2026PayPal reported Q1 2026 results and gave details of its new operating model. It guided 2026 non-GAAP EPS from a low-single-digit decline to slightly positive.
  • April 29, 2026PayPal reorganized into three businesses: Checkout Solutions & PayPal, Consumer Financial Services & Venmo, and Payment Services & Crypto. The heads of the Consumer Group and of the Small Business & Financial Services Group left the company.

Similar companies

  • CSUConstellation SoftwareShares: AI disruption risk, New management
    Discount
    6.3%
    LSEG
    2.00
    Gap
    Slow
  • EXPGYExperianShares: AI disruption risk, Weak consumer
    Discount
    31.4%
    LSEG
    1.67
    Gap
    Slow
  • ROLRollinsShares: AI disruption risk, New management
    Discount
    26.6%
    LSEG
    2.75
    Gap
    Can close
  • ADBEAdobeShares: AI disruption risk, New management
    Discount
    26.8%
    LSEG
    2.77
    Gap
    Slow
  • CHKPCheck PointShares: New management, AI disruption risk
    Discount
    31.3%
    LSEG
    2.46
    Gap
    Can close

Read it all? Star PYPL or pass, then go on to the next one.